Friday, February 15, 2008

School and competition

Today was form morning at Chubbocks's school, where all the youngest kids were performing a circus. Before the act began, the director of the school came up on stage to address us, and his talk was really interesting and thought-provoking. He said that in Germany, Sweden, France etc, schooling doesn't begin until the age of six. It was only in the Uk, way back in Victorian England during the industrial revolution that people started to send their kids off to school early so that the kids would finish their education fast and be available as juvenile and therefore poorly paid workers for the factories...and since India inherited her education system from the UK, that's what we do, though possibly not with the same objectives today. He also said that a lot of research on the issue of early versus late schooling had not resulted in a win for either side, though earlier schooling was only considered helpful if it helped a child develop his or her natural abilities, without the stress of competition.

I'm a pretty laid-back parent in that sense, and can't be fussed about making sure my kids are meeting their milestones, except basic health-related ones. I remember once when Chubbocks was in playschool, he had to take part in some such performance but was too shy and lolled about on stage. Shortly thereafter, A had to leave for office and that made Chubbocks burst into tears. Immediately all the teachers and the principal of his playschool were on me like a pack of wolves, explaining that I shouldn't scold the child for not doing his part and that this was no age to submit the child to competitive pressure and so on. I was taken aback and eventually managed to tell them what was going on, but I don't know how many of them believed me. I was a little irritated at the time, but later I realised that I should be thankful that we had chosen such a nice playschool, whose focus was not on 'getting kids ready for the admission process' but on helping them discover themselves. That school was an amazing boon for Chubbocks and helped turn him from a shy child into a confident, articulate little communicator, so much so that he always gets kudos for his verbal skills.

At the start of today's program, the director also made the point that in case any of the kids didn't do what they were supposed to on stage or did their own thing, we were there to celebrate their spontaneity and creativity, and their confidence in just coming up on stage. Different kids learned at different ages because the neural connections grew at different paces. Reminded me of the message from TZP all over again, and I was again grateful that we had decided to put Chubbocks into this school.

BTW, Chubbocks was a mighty lion in the circus - and a darn cute one too. he wanted to bring his ears and mane home but his 'ma'am didn't let him!

12 comments:

Aryan-Arjun said...

Oh ..where are the photos..love to see lion chubbocks...Nice post
Aryan's mom

bird's eye view said...

Aryan's mom - I'll have to ask my husband to upload the pics - am new to the new camera so I can only hope I got some good ones.

noon said...

Hi Bev - first time here.
Wow - I am really impressed with Chubbock's preschool. First time here, so have to go back to your posts to see how old he is - assume 3 or 4...It's really surprising in some way (about how his teachers told you not to scold him) - popular assumption (incl mine) is that in India the teachers are quite strict and they probably would not have been so balanced about it...not just balanced they had the right perspective...yes, would love to see pics! do let me know if u post 'em.

noon said...

Tagged you...

bird's eye view said...

Noon,

Chubbocks is almost five - I can hardly believe it myself! But his school is one of the more progressive schools - there are some like that but the majority do tend to be the 'pushing the comparison and grading agenda' type of schools. Will let you know when I manage to put up the pictures.

bird's eye view said...

noon - will do the tag soon...it requires thinking about :)

mummyjaan said...

(I see somebody's made their profile public!)

I really worry about this aspect because, God-willing, we will return to India. I'd like my children to be in schools which focus on development of the child as a whole, not just on learning from a fixed curriculum.

Apparently, there are 7 different varieties of intelligence, and our educational system only recognized and rewards 1 or 2 of these.

mummyjaan said...

*recognizes

(damn! another typo!)

Mona said...

hey, thank you for your comment over at my blog.
i'm really impressed with the playschool chubbocks goes to :) i hope i can find something similar here when it's time for hana.

Choxbox said...

first time here.

wow. you mean such schools exist?

bird's eye view said...

mummyjaan - yes, techno-challenged me finally realised I had made my profile private only after months of blogging!Hope my profile doesn't scare you off :) There are a few such schools in every city now, as more parents also feel that the pure academic-type focus isn't wholesome, so I'm sure you'll be able to find one whenever you move back.
Mona - you're welcome. I hope you find such a school there too - if not, I suppose the international schools are always an option.
Choxbox - yes, they do exist, thank God!

RaisingT said...

Tagged..