Thursday, June 12, 2008

Summer Holidays

If you live in any of india's big cities, you will find yourself inundated with ads and newspaper inserts advertising summer camps and activity centers for kids. And you will find many of them full to the brim of kids, all learning to do colouring or to sing songs or whatever. Whatever happened to the carefree schedule-free days of summer?

I don't know whether it's purely a function of working moms, because several of my son's classmates who have stay-at-home moms are also enrolled in these classes. Last year, after we got back from a 2 week vacation, we enrolled Chubbocks into a thrice-a-week three hours summer camp, because my mom was away in the US and I didn't want him drifting around with nothing to do. Yet I'm a bit upset that I did it because I think it's so important for kids to learn the art of simply being as well as amusing themselves.

As a mom, while I don't believe in 'quality time', I do believe in benign neglect. I think it does kids a world of good to just hang out in the same space as their parents, not necessarily being read to/ taught/ 'spoken to'/ made to do anything in particular which is meant to mark the time the parent spent with the kid as something special. When I look back at my own childhood, what I see is a string of days or a blurred period of time where we all hung out, chatted, fought, played, cried and laughed together. The undue emphasis on quality time just leads kids to think the world revolves around them and they never learn to just coexist in the same space as other people, without the warm shininess of a spotlight.

This summer, though I knew I wouldn't have too much time off, I didn't want to enrol Chubbocks into any classes, especially those that taught him anything. I think school is good enough for most things he wants or needs to learn. So we just put him into a dance class that's an hour twice a week, as some of his friends from school were joining up as well and that was that.

Of course, it has led to him moping around the house, as I feared. It's bizarre but he doesn't have any company around, despite the fact that the colony we live in is full of kids his age. That's because these days, parents just don't send their kids out to play because 'it's too hot'. I remember during my summer vacations, we were forever outside, jumping, running, shouting and playing, oblivious to the weather. We only came home for lunch and the afternoon nap and the evening too would pass in merry mayhem. The high point of a day would be a trip with parents to the India Gate lawns where we would chill on the cool grass near a fountain so some of the spray would fall on us, and have an ice cream or so ( me only the cone because I had bronchitis). There was nothing organised about our entertainment, and yet we managed very well, be it playing Blindman's Bluff or catch-catch, organising Telematch tournaments or playing hide and seek in the dim gardens that ran behind our homes. The local library was raided week after week, while old books were lent and borrowed. I made an entire set of posters of all my favourite comic book heroes - from Phantom to Mandrake to Richie Rich - to decorate my playroom, one summer.

I wonder if we as parents are becoming over-protective of our kids, in the process robbing them of the ability to think freely and learn to get along with the elements. Of course, no one wants kids to fall ill with heat stroke, but a bottle of water/ nimbu paani and a summer hat should be fine protection except during the dog-hours of noon, no? Even at birthday parties, the amusement is organised and orchestrated so that our poor kids lose the ability to come up with games for themselves. Can you imagine the well-groomed kids you see at a typical birthday party coming up with anything as subversive and creative as Calvin-Ball?

I hate the words, "I'm bored", and have banned them from our house. I can't remember being bored once, though we used to have few books or games at home and of course television didn't come into our home until we were much older. This generation of kids, with so many toys and books and games, still manages to find the time to get bored. How?

Chubbocks has managed his vacation time okay so far, between hanging out with his grandparents and writing out little notes on his doodlepad. Now we have my cousin visiting, with her kids, so that's a new source of enjoyment for Chubbocks. next year i'm planning to definitely take 3 weeks off during summer so that even if we don't go anywhere, I'm there for my kids to hang out with. And yet i'm clear that I don't want to be organising anything - camp or playdate. I want them to find their own playtimes and games, with each other or by themselves, though I'm never averse to jumping into a puddle of water.

"What is this life if full of care
We have no time to stand and stare
No time to stand beneath the bows
And stare as long as sheep or cows...?

10 comments:

dipali said...

I've just read a whole bunch of your posts after many days, and thoroughly enjoyed reading them and seeing your absolutely adorable kids. They are both so beautiful. And you look like a beautiful ship in full sail!
The Mad family are wonderful to meet.
Hope Chubbocks enjoys his unstructured vacation- I'm definitely with you on this one- children need to develop their own resources without getting bored! (Horrid word)

Anonymous said...

"The undue emphasis on quality time just leads kids to think the world revolves around them and they never learn to just coexist in the same space as other people, without the warm shininess of a spotlight."

OH MY GOD! its what i believe in most! why don't other parents (the ones around me at least!) get it??? why? why? why? i wish i could print your post and hand it out to them!

because i don't have a lot of very good help, my kids are around me all the time, but because i'd go insane if i was to entertain them all that time i just do my own thing around them and they do their own thing sitting around me. it works perfectly for us! (for the most part! he he)

d

Sonia said...

You are so right !! Its difficult not to get caught up in the peer pressure too; I see my friends with 6 mnths old babies enrolling them in swim classes, gym classes and I dont understand what is the rush ! Is there a necessity to have small kids well versed in a thousand languages and a hundred sports by age 2?

I remember my summer holidays back in Mumbai; me and my bldg friends had even built a complete zhopdi out of coconut tree branches. I hope my baby girl also can enjoy a similar care free fun summer all thru her childhood as I have..

noon said...

Hey BEV - I think the days of summer vacations spent doing nothing but playing in the hot sun are gone for ever! And for us with kids here in the US and every other kid only going to classes or "scheduling" play dates - it is officially gone - outside play time! Sad demise of something wonderful. My cousin and I recall our days in our native village - it would be scorching by 10.00 am but we used to play - like you said - at all times except when we had to eat and when it was truly unbearably hot - in which case we used to come inside the house to play cards! We used to go to the river early in the morning to bathe and return when it was too hot to be there...some days search parties used to walk some 15 minutes to the river wondering where we went! Even I would not send my child out like that now...
I am dreading these decisions you know...for us here in the US - on regular weekends (not summer) there is the additional pressure of "Bal Vihar" too! And Indian parents go nuts with Abacus classes and Kumon for reading and Math! And they learn one Indian instrument/one western/one sport/swimming...I mean at age 5 or 6 - they are the busiest things on the planet! And like my friend says - if the other kids in the class cope and "know" all of this, then you wonder if you are doing the right thing in just letting the kid be by taking just one class or two! Insane - all this pressure!
Enjoyed your post - as you can see from my reaction! :))

bird's eye view said...

Thanks Dipali. I think I was channelling the Titanic that day in Goa...the ship, not Kate, LOL!

anonymous - it's true, kids do learn to play by themselves, as long as you let them. And boy does it make life easier for us ( evil grin!)

Kiran, I think the whole stress of 'competitive world out there' and structured learning is driving parents a little crazy. My kids are trilingual but because we've been speaking to them in those 3 languages at home, not classes. The more structured we make their days, the more tightly wound up they'll be as adults, no? It's really up to us parents to say it's ok to take life at a slower pace and enjoy free time and learn by being and doing rather than attending all kinds of classes.

noon - your childhood sounds idyllic. Even me - when I'd get together with my cousins, all our parents cared about was that we made it home for meals. The rest of the day they were abso clueless about where we were and what we were doing, which is so relaxing for everybody! My crib is that I live in a gated community and even here no one sends their kids out. I'm doing my best to stay out of the kid rat race, because it's so easy and yet so unrewarding to get caught up in the whole thing...

Sukhaloka said...

Oh, I totally agree :).
It's happening to a lot of us teens too - I just caught myself in this computer-induced zombieness, and am consciously trying to spend less time on the Net, searching for stimulation and entertainment outside instead of from my own head.
Also, all this emphasis on stuff originating from the outside tends to eat away at self-esteem on the inside, or so I feel.

Yay for benign neglect :)

Mystic Margarita said...

So true. Kids are so burdened with activities these days that they don't get much chance to enjoy their childhood. A pity.

Mona said...

too true.
quality time is something i don't give a lot of thought too either.
great post, p!
and the pictures in your goa holiday one were fab - i say this all the time and i will repeat - your kids are gorgeous!

Swati said...

I believe , we need a balance, like you said , just one dance class. So that they dont feel bored and do something they like. Over burdening the kids is definitely not good. Did a post about it long back.

http://myamusingmind.blogspot.com/2007/07/apart-from-school-he-goes-to-skating.html

bird's eye view said...

Suki - am practicing being more zen by neglecting my kids :)

MM - bizarrely enough, yesterday Chubbocks started telling us he'd like to do more classes since all his friends are in at least 3 classes!!! Peer pressure starts early...

Mona - thanks!! And Goa was fab...the kind of holiday one looks back at for years as an idyll...

Swati - will check out your post, thanks for sending me the link.